Cat Johnson

  • About
  • Lab
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Events
  • Contact
  • About
  • Lab
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Freelance Writing
  • Comma Drama: What is the Oxford Comma and Why Do We Care?

Freelance Writing

09 Sep

Comma Drama: What is the Oxford Comma and Why Do We Care?

  • In Freelance Writing, Pro Tips, Writing
  • 3 comments

Comma Drama- What is the Oxford Comma and

Who ever thought a comma would be at the heart of an international debate? Certainly not me, but the Oxford comma is proving to be quite a little trouble-maker.

What is the Oxford comma?

The Oxford comma (sometimes called the serial comma, or Harvard comma) is a comma placed immediately before the coordinating conjunction (usually and, or, or nor) in a series of three or more terms. For most of us, it’s the comma we’ve always been told we could leave out when listing things.

For example, I was taught to write, “Santa Cruz, San Francisco and Oakland.” But Oxford comma users would write that phrase like this: “Santa Cruz, San Francisco, and Oakland.”

See how that little comma snuck in there before “and Oakland”? That’s the Oxford comma.

So what’s all the ruckus about the Oxford comma? Well, grammarians can’t agree on whether it should be used or not.

Some big publications and guides, including the Oxford Style Manual (hence the name), the Chicago Manual of Style, The MLA Style Manual, Strunk and White’s Elements of Style, and the U.S. Government Printing Office Style Manual, mandate use of the Oxford comma, while the Associated Press Stylebook, the New York Times stylebook, and the Economist style guide advise against it.

Why the confusion and disagreement? If clarity is the priority, a case can be made that in some instances the Oxford comma clarifies the meaning of a sentence, and in others, it confuses the meaning. As with any good debate, a case can be made both for and against it.

A case for the Oxford comma:

“She took a photograph of her parents, the president, and the vice president.”
This is a classic example from the Chicago Manual of Style. Without the Oxford comma, this reads that the subject’s parents are the president and the vice president.

A case against the Oxford comma:

“I dedicate this book to my father, Burt Reynolds, and America.”

With the Oxford comma, this example reads that the author’s father is Burt Reynolds. Removing the Oxford comma clarifies that there are three entities being referred to: “I dedicate this book to my father, Burt Reynolds and America.”

The following popular (and entertaining) example in support of the Oxford comma has been making the rounds on social media recently:

I will fight to support the Oxford comma until I draw my last breath. pic.twitter.com/Y0T6c3F4iI

— Alexander MacDonald (@alex_macdonald) April 30, 2015

If you’d like to follow along in the Oxford comma debate, search the Twitter hashtag #OxfordComma. You can also see what side of the debate celebrities fall by following @CelebrityOxford on Twitter. While you’re at it, follow @IAmOxfordComma, whose profile reads, “I am the oxford comma. I resolve ambiguity. Sometimes I also create ambiguity.”

Still not sure which side of the debate you stand on? The following image makes another case for why it should be used.

OxfordCommaIllustration

Since there is no agreement about the Oxford comma among the biggest publications and style guides, the general rule is to find out what the publication you’re writing for calls for. If there’s no rule in place, choose to either use it or not, and stick with your decision. You don’t want an article or blog post to have some sentences with the Oxford comma and others without it.

So, that’s the comma drama surrounding the Oxford comma. It’s a grammar nerd tug-o-war over a tiny little mark, with no end in sight.

Which way do you sway with the Oxford comma?

Top photo: quatrostaggioni (CC-BY)
Follow @CatJohnson on Twitter

Tags:debategrammarOxford CommapunctuationWhat is the Oxford comma
  • Share:
Cat Johnson
I help coworking space operators streamline and level-up their marketing. I'm a writer, content strategist and brand community builder based in Santa Cruz, California. Current projects include: Coworking Convos and the Coworking Content Lab workspace marketing club.

You may also like

marketing-resolutions

Keep Your Marketing Resolutions: 6 Tips for Workspace Operators

  • December 28, 2020
  • by Cat Johnson
  • in Marketing and Branding
Here we go again with another round of New Year’s resolutions. We always have the...
community-impact
How to Measure the Community Impact of Coworking
November 17, 2020
holiday-marketing-coworking
Get Back to Basics with Your Holiday Marketing
November 10, 2020
writing-routine
How to Create a Writing Routine (and Stick with It)
November 3, 2020

    Comments

  1. Stephanie
    September 15, 2015

    I am laughing so hard at the examples! Pretty nerdy for me, but a very interesting read on a little punctuation mark I never thought so hard about. I like the decision to pick a side and stay consistent, but it seems in certain cases it should be independently determined (as evidenced by the examples).
    Thanks for another fun read Cat.

    Reply
    • cat johnson
      September 15, 2015

      You’re welcome! So glad you enjoyed it, Stephanie.

      The examples are funny. I think the extreme (somewhat ridiculous ones) make people sit up and actually give the Oxford comma some thought.

      Absolutely, there are examples both ways. The key thing with consistency is making sure that in one article you either use it, or not. It looks sloppy to use it in one sentence, then not use it in another.

      Cheers,
      Cat

      Reply
  2. Steve
    January 15, 2020

    I know I’m 5 yrs late to the party but I have to comment as this is bugging me.

    Your examples don’t show the issue with the Oxford comma – they just show a particular problem with the English language. Proof of this is that you show the same problem with or without the comma, therefore obviously the specific issue you’re showing in these examples isn’t caused or solved by the comma. That problem will remain regardless.

    What the Oxford comma does do, is it stops the last two items on a list from being grouped together. For example “For breakfast I had toast, eggs and orange juice” implies that the eggs and orange juice were mixed together in a yucky mush. The Oxford comma would separate these to read “For breakfast I had toast, eggs, and orange juice”

    Reply

Leave A Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Each week I send content tips, info and curated articles to 2,342 coworking space operators. Want in?
"Cat Johnson is the marketing maven of the coworking world. She delivers content that is real, actionable and on-point. If you want to learn how to ignite your marketing and storytelling, you found the person. Enjoy the journey."
Liz Elam
Executive Producer, GCUC
"Working with Cat is like a breath of fresh air. She knows the coworking industry inside and out, and her understanding of what makes great content is second to none. And if that weren’t enough, she’s organized, thorough, and simply a delight to work with."
Susan Dorsch
Cofounder, Office Nomads
"Cat is the go-to when it comes to content strategy for the shared workspace industry. Not only is she an expert but she is immersed in coworking. She really gets it. Her newsletter is one of the few in my inbox that gets opened every week."
Jamie Russo
Everything Coworking Podcast, GWA
"Cat is a unique and powerful voice in the coworking movement. She’s dedicated to learning about what’s happening from every possible angle, analyzing what she finds, and sharing everything so we can all benefit. Coworking is better because Cat is part of it."
Tony Bacigalupo
Founder, New Work Cities

© Cat Johnson

COWORKING · CONTENT · COMMUNITY

Each week I send content tips, info and curated articles to 2,342 coworking space operators. Want in?